Local News
5 Minutes

Windham hotel dispute shows no signs of checking out

Published on:
November 13, 2026
The hotel is already being promoted on Windham Mountain Club’s website (windhammountainclub.com/stay) as “Boutique Hotel: Coming 2028.”
Article by:
Michael Ryan
Reporter
, Porcupine Soup
Share

WINDHAM—A seemingly mundane Windham Planning Board meeting has ramped up already escalating resistance to the ongoing review of a potential new hotel at the Windham Mountain Club.

Town planning board members, on November 5, spent more than an hour painstakingly plodding through a plethora of proposed changes to the ski center’s previously approved development master plan.

That plan was conditionally approved last year, involving 60 townhouses on ski center lands. The Windham Mountain Club (WMC) now wants to replace a number of those residential units with a 26-room luxury hotel and four villas.

A State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) evaluation was conducted over the past few months and, in late October, the planning board issued a negative declaration―determining that the proposed changes would not have significant adverse environmental impacts and that a more extensive environmental impact statement would not be required.

Controversy and drama have arisen, however, as a group of local hoteliers has asked for a pause in the overall approval process, challenging the validity of the planning board amid multiple member recusals.

And fresh fuel has perhaps been added to that growing furor based upon the optics surrounding one of the recused members during the otherwise ho-hum November 5 planning board session.

Three members with work or membership links to the WMC have recused themselves from discussions and any decision-making, wanting to remove any appearance of a conflict of interest.

Since then, the board has legally proceeded with only three members. But the group of local hoteliers, led by Wylder Windham owner John Flannigan, is questioning the rightness of the process.

Joined by state Senator Michelle Hinchey, they have raised doubts regarding the status of a fourth member, Chairwoman Lisa Jaeger, while requesting that the Windham Town Board step in.

Hinchey, in an October 22 letter to the planning and town boards, stated, “I write today with a deep love of Windham, and that love is driving a genuine concern for its long term stability and overall future.”

“When my now-husband and I decided to get married… we chose Windham as the backdrop and got married at a local hotel in 2025,” she wrote, referring to Wylder Windham.

“I have strong concerns about the proposed change to the Windham Mountain Club’s plan and the process surrounding its consideration,” Hinchey continued.

“The fact that only two members of the five-member planning board, along with an alternate, are making such a consequential decision about the town’s future is deeply concerning and raises serious questions about the legitimacy of the process and fair consideration,” Hinchey wrote.

“These concerns are further heightened by the fact that [Jaeger] also chairs the [Windham] Chamber of Commerce, whose organization is financially tied to the applicant,” Hinchey wrote.

The ski center, for many years, has contributed to the success of the annual Autumn Affair, a street festival sponsored by the Chamber.

And the current WMC president and hotel applicant, Kristen Leach, serves on the Chamber board of directors with Jaeger.

If the fourth recusal occurred, it would reduce the planning board to two members―likely halting the review process and potentially nullifying all actions that have thus far taken place regarding the hotel application.

Jaeger has issued a statement declaring that her volunteer role with the Chamber is “separate and distinct” from her planning post, each fully transparent with no inherent conflict of interest.

And the planning board’s special counsel, Allyson Phillips, in an October 15 memo, stated Jaeger “is not party to any agreements with the applicant whereby she may receive a payment or other benefit that is contingent or dependent on the planning board granting a favorable approval.”

Town Supervisor Thomas Hoyt and town board members have made their thinking clear: the planning board is operating independently of the town board, with review and conflict-of-interest matters unfolding as they should.

Nevertheless, in her October 22 letter, Hinchey wrote, “I urge the town to reconsider its previous determination for a negative [SEQRA] declaration in light of this project’s potentially massive impact on the community.”

“Further, even if one is not legally required, a feasibility study is the right step to take in order to do necessary due diligence, provide transparency and to understand the long term impacts to the town itself,” she wrote.

Hinchey, in an earlier October 15 letter to the two boards, referenced a “feasibility study,” writing, “I join the calls of local businesses and residents asking to see the feasibility study for this project.”

“The public has a right to see this document, and the longer it is shrouded in secrecy, the larger the appearance of impropriety,” she wrote.

Subsequent interviews by the Mountain Eagle with various officials tied directly to the project revealed that the feasibility study did not exist.

Hinchey, in her October 22 letter, stepped back, clarifying that the “previous version of this letter requested the release of a feasibility study as I was under the impression one had been conducted.”

While not detailing the reason for her impression, Hinchey wrote, “I apologize for that incorrect information as I have not seen a feasibility study in the public record.”

The lack of that study, however, “is equally as troubling to me,” the senator wrote. “I would urge [the planning and town boards] to step in now, stop this proposal from moving forward and provide residents with the transparency they deserve.”

Leach, in a November 4 response to the senator, stated, in part, “Senator Hinchey’s suggestion is based on a ludicrous false premise and by her own admission is not a legitimate and legally supported requirement.”

“The town of Windham has +/-372 hotel rooms available for booking and another +/-489 AirBnb or VRBO rental,” Leach wrote, adding that the “addition of 30 luxury hotel rooms is insignificant in relation to what the market currently comprises.”

“The Senator’s suggestion ignores the overwhelming positive economic effects of WMC activities related to the recent applications before the planning board,” Leach stated.

“As the [SEQRA] determination has been made, the application is complete, and the public hearing has been closed,” Leach wrote. “We respectfully request the planning board move forward with its review of the request for amendment to preliminary plat and site plan.”

Flannigan and Albergo Allegria hotel owner Marianna Radelich-Leman, who have signed the letter asking for the WMC pause, were at the latest November 5 planning board meeting, recording the proceedings.

The meeting was marked by tedious, albeit necessary, line-by-line comparisons of what the planning board had earlier approved and what they are now reviewing.

One recused planning board member, Ray Curtis, was sitting in the audience next to Leach, who is a regular attendee. Curtis returned to the head table after the discussions about the WMC ended.

Flannigan, in a November 9 letter to Hoyt, took strong exception to the optics, stating, “I am writing regarding yet another troubling incident involving the Windham Mountain Club hotel application.”

Flannigan stated Curtis was “speaking and whispering with [Leach] while the applicant's consultants were presenting to the planning board.”

“We have expressly rejected and challenged Ms. Phillips's prior conclusions concerning the conflicts in this matter,” Flannigan wrote.

“I call on you to initiate an independent review of the conflicts and recusals involving this application and reconsider whether the proceedings should begin anew before an appropriately constituted planning board,” Flannigan wrote to Hoyt.

A 62-day deadline for issuing a final decision on the hotel project began on October 15 and can be extended if agreed upon by all parties.

The next planning board meeting is slated for November 19, when officials are expected to continue their review in public.