Local News
6 Minutes

Jewett officials face federal whistleblower lawsuit

Published on:
November 20, 2026
Jewett Highway Superintendent Robert Mallory and Town Clerk Maya Carl have filed a federal lawsuit against four members of the Town Board, alleging retaliation for reporting possible illegal activity to the Greene County Sheriff's Office.
Article by:
Michael Ryan
Reporter
, Porcupine Soup
Share

JEWETT—Jewett Highway Superintendent Robert Mallory and Town Clerk Maya Carl have filed a federal lawsuit against four members of the Town Board, alleging retaliation for reporting possible illegal activity to the Greene County Sheriff's Office.

Town Supervisor Greg Kroyer, Councilmen John Giordano and James Pellitteri, Councilwoman Jeanie Scotti and the town of Jewett are named as defendants in the suit, which contains 43 causes of action.

"The four named town board members,"  the lawsuit alleges,  "knew [Mallory and Carl] to be whistleblowers that reported unlawful action" by those four government officials.

The suit alleges that Mallory and Carl have been subjected to an escalating pattern of retaliation since reporting their concerns to authorities. The East Greenbush law firm of Salazar and Erikson, representing Mallory and Carl, is demanding a jury trial.

The allegations come amid what the Greene County Sheriff's Office has called an "ongoing investigation."

Sheriff's investigators executed a search warrant at Jewett Town Hall in July 2025 in response to what Sheriff's Captain Joel Rowell described as "allegations of potentially fraudulent activity."

Rowell said at the time that a team of investigators seized "electronic devices, paper files and business records."

A second sheriff's search was carried out October 7, 2026, on Deer Valley Lane, a remote dead-end road where Jewett Planning Board Chairwoman Barbara Schobel lives. Multiple patrol cars and a K-9 unit were involved.

Schobel is referenced in a January 2026 notice of claim submitted by Mallory and Carl as a prerequisite to their lawsuit.

According to that notice of claim, a subsequent notice of claim and the federal lawsuit filed November 11, Mallory became aware in fall 2024 that a private building was being constructed on property owned by Schobel and that a foundation had been laid.

On April 16, 2025, Mallory and Carl requested a meeting with Kroyer to discuss what they believed was illegal construction that had not been inspected.

"Kroyer downplayed the reported misconduct and code violations, but nonetheless requested time to resolve the issue," the lawsuit states.

Mallory and Carl requested a second meeting with Kroyer on April 23 and notified Town Attorney Tal Rappleyea of their concerns the following day. According to the lawsuit, they also discussed the issues with Town Board members over the next several weeks, but no action was taken to address the alleged misconduct or code violations.

After receiving no resolution from town officials, Mallory and Carl reported their concerns about the construction on Schobel's property to the Greene County Sheriff's Office, according to the lawsuit.

Their report came approximately two months before the initial sheriff's search.

A third sheriff's search warrant was also recently executed, apparently extending the investigation beyond town borders. Sheriff's officials, however, have not disclosed the specific focus of any of their searches.

In addition to the new federal lawsuit, Mallory and Carl previously filed two separate Article 78 proceedings against the Town Board in New York State Supreme Court, both of which remain ongoing.

The first, filed in June, challenges the town's credit card and security policies, while the second, filed in July, concerns changes to the town's health insurance policies. Mallory and Carl allege that the actions challenged in both proceedings were "punitive, arbitrary, capricious, and an abuse of power."

Attorney James Peluso, representing the town, denied the allegations in the Article 78 litigation.

"[Mallory's and Carl's] bald, conclusory allegation that the policies were adopted as part of a conspiracy by the Town Board to retaliate against [Mallory and Carl] is speculative, lacks any competent proof, is belied by the record, and demonstrates a pattern of lawfare by [Mallory and Carl] in filing baseless charges against [the town]," Peluso stated.

Kroyer, in an affidavit connected to the policy dispute, said Mallory's and Carl's argument that the policies were "manufactured" without any notice was incorrect.

"The Town Board acted within its power to adopt the policies which are designed to improve security and internal controls…not an arbitrary, personal act directed against [Mallory and Carl]," Kroyer stated.

The federal lawsuit also contains allegations of defamation against Kroyer and Pellitteri, who allegedly "during the last election in the fall of 2025, told members of the public that [Mallory and Carl] were liars and troublemakers."

"This statement exposed [Mallory and Carl] to public hatred, ridicule, or disgrace. This statement would lead the average person in the community to form a bad opinion of [Mallory and Carl]," the lawsuit states.

The federal complaint further alleges violations of New York Civil Service Law Section 75-b, intentional infliction of emotional distress, creation of a hostile work environment, civil conspiracy and other state and federal legal claims.

Town officials have not responded to the notices of claim on the advice of counsel. A phone message left for Kroyer on November 17 regarding the new lawsuit was not returned.

"As a direct and proximate result of Defendant Town of Jewett's retaliatory actions against [Mallory and Carl], they have suffered and continue to suffer, in an amount to be determined at trial, a loss of past and future income, monetary damages, humiliation, severe emotional distress, mental and physical anguish and suffering, and damage to their professional reputation," the lawsuit states.

Mallory and Carl are seeking unspecified compensatory and punitive damages, attorney fees, court costs and other relief the court deems appropriate.